Quote from: Ngati_Grim;1311977Finally though, I see the Abrahamic religions as the Axis of Evil. There is a war for our minds. It is being waged by the forces for rationality and the forces for superstition.That's how I percieve it.QuoteGrim, you are fighting a battle that cannot be won.
Finally though, I see the Abrahamic religions as the Axis of Evil. There is a war for our minds. It is being waged by the forces for rationality and the forces for superstition.That's how I percieve it.
Grim, you are fighting a battle that cannot be won.
Every field of human knowledge is afflicted by varying degrees of superstition, from Physics to Accounting.
We should aim to free the organising of our societies from any organised religion and superstitions, not just theism. Trying to relieve theists of their faith is counter-productive, people need to find some sort of comfort in this grotesque universe. But at no point should any of us be so arrogant to assume, for example, that our "personal relationship with Jesus Christ" should apply to anybody else.
Who_Ate_My_Rice , Since you seem incapable of answering my question directly
I guess I will have to answer it for you. Maybe it was my intention after all; you are not completely wrong in accusing me of Sophism! I find it difficult to consider you a reasonable person
when you say that you think sin and virtue should be governed by reason, not superstition, and then say without (superstitious) faith we can find no salvation in our virtue. Surely that would not matter to a being worthy of my devotion.
And anyway, if I should find myself in "Heaven" I very much suspect it will be a punishment, as heaven is going to be filled by most accounts with insufferably smug, brittle minded winners of idiotic wagers of faith. Hell is where all the interesting people are going from what I hear. How am I to know what everlasting happiness is without some suffering, anyway? Better to Masturbate in Hell than to Suck Dick in Heaven.
Anything outside the observable universe is in the god box.I got re-interested in this thread because of Rices comments re: what you woudl say if god appeared in front of you. My position is that if he/she/it appears in front of you, then they aren't god(s)The problem is that gods by their very definition are unfalsifiable. If gods become measurable and explicable, they're just science. Which is why peoples gods always move to fill the bits science hasn't got to.
Just wondering, Rice... How can you be certain your level of belief is the correct one? I mean, how do you know that your interperetation (which is indeed something completely separate from the morals taught by the old testament) is the correct interperetation over say, the Christian from another church next door, who may indeed be destined to go to heaven where you are determined to go to hell?You say your faith is based on your personal relationship with Jesus, and follow his morals written in the New Testament, and that's what will eventually get you into heaven. How do you know his teachings, or indeed his existence, to be true?
I feel everyone should know I have recently joined The Church of Harold.
Our universe, which started with the Big Bang.
Perhaps I'll just escape through a wormhole.
But then ofcourse you're running into the verification principle which disproves itself. And yes you are right doctor God is unfalsifiable. But remember a statement doesnt need to be falsifiable for it to be accepted as true. You could then go on to say, Atheism is falsifiable, and it is falsified, and therefore its negation which is theism is true.
Quote from: Spacemonkey;1312129Our universe, which started with the Big Bang.Last i checked it was still called teh Big Bang Theory. have a read of this. You might scoff but i cant be bothered typing this stuff out. http://www.answersingenesis.org/articles/am/v3/n1/big-bang-gods-chosen-methodand if you say string theory is the solution to what came before. Again its a theory. we have no solid evidence and until then we can only speculate. but hey~~ thats why they constructed teh LHC right!
Can you imagine people applying such thinking to other fields of study? What if historians rejected recorded history and claimed that World War I never happened because their philosophy does not allow for the possibility of a world war? Would this be reasonable?There simply isn’t any good reason to believe in the big bang. It is not compatible with the Bible, and it’s not good science.
Last i checked it was still called teh Big Bang Theory. have a read of this. You might scoff but i cant be bothered typing this stuff out. http://www.answersingenesis.org/articles/am/v3/n1/big-bang-gods-chosen-method
Couple of things id like to dispute.Ok in reverse chronological order.wormholes are a legit part of physicssee: matt visser lorentzian wormholes ebook
QuoteBut then ofcourse you're running into the verification principle which disproves itself. And yes you are right doctor God is unfalsifiable. But remember a statement doesnt need to be falsifiable for it to be accepted as true. You could then go on to say, Atheism is falsifiable, and it is falsified, and therefore its negation which is theism is true.You dont want to go down this road, it means you could never EVER prove the existence of god.Besides, if something isnt falsifiable it means we cant observe it, even when we're dead, which implies that there is no heaven/hell if you assume religion is unfalsifiable.The fact of the matter is, unless youre worshipping some pretty strange religion, god has to have existed at some point to create everything, and to inseminate mary etc etc etc, and assuming he lives in some "heaven", this place must exist somewhere, ergo it is falsifiable.
Quote from: Who_ate_my_rice;1312255Quote from: Spacemonkey;1312129Our universe, which started with the Big Bang.Last i checked it was still called teh Big Bang Theory. have a read of this. You might scoff but i cant be bothered typing this stuff out. http://www.answersingenesis.org/articles/am/v3/n1/big-bang-gods-chosen-methodand if you say string theory is the solution to what came before. Again its a theory. we have no solid evidence and until then we can only speculate. but hey~~ thats why they constructed teh LHC right! I have no quarrel with you good sir. But don't get started with this "Last I checked is was still a theory" bullcrap, what's that supposed to mean?I have nothing against someone believing that the big bang was how god created the universe, that's fine with me.But there is lots of 'solid' evidence for the Big bang, and I don't really see why you are bringing String theory into this.
QuoteCan you imagine people applying such thinking to other fields of study? What if historians rejected recorded history and claimed that World War I never happened because their philosophy does not allow for the possibility of a world war? Would this be reasonable?There simply isnt any good reason to believe in the big bang. It is not compatible with the Bible, and its not good science. That link is just terrible. I mean when i saw genesis in the url, i wasn't expecting much, but it is dare i say it has some absurd bits in it. Like SM says, i don't mind someone saying the big bang was an act of god, but to start disputing it using the bible is quite worrying.
Can you imagine people applying such thinking to other fields of study? What if historians rejected recorded history and claimed that World War I never happened because their philosophy does not allow for the possibility of a world war? Would this be reasonable?There simply isnt any good reason to believe in the big bang. It is not compatible with the Bible, and its not good science.
Also on the side, i find it interesting everyone seems to be arguing against the Abrahamic religions, and mainly Christianity.
Oh btw nothing happened before the big bang, time began at the same instant as space.
We shall scoff so much we choke to death, this is the battle.
You imagine that I hold unjustified prejudices against Christianity and expect me relieve myself of them by reading this "bible",
and yet you hold worse prejudices against scientific theory
based on what I can only assume how you think most people think based on the death-grip biblical fallacy holds over your mind.
We don't "believe" in the Big Bang Theory, we have no faith in it. It is merely what we think is the most likely model for the history of the universe. We can say this because the universe has a number of features pointing to a violent expansion from a single point, the most prominent being the Cosmic Microwave Background Radiation which fills the heavens. You are correct in pointing out there are a number holes in this theory, but what would you have us do?
And why should I read the bible to satisfy your perverse lust to infect my mind with your preachy fairy stories?
Not just everything, everywhere and everywhen came into being too. There wasnt anything before so its not like it magically appeared, the universe always was and always will be.
Quote from: Blob_ZPS;1312311Not just everything, everywhere and everywhen came into being too. There wasnt anything before so its not like it magically appeared, the universe always was and always will be.how can you create soemthing out of nothing? or if it always existed, then it had come to being before the big bang, in which case how? I migth be misunderstanding you here NOW FOR THAT BEAUTY SLEEP!
Can you give me some evidence bru~ would be cool to have a look. nothign being smart here, im seriously asking.
ah~ see Toofast, its not to us because if we can't believe in the bible to tell us how the world began, how can we rely on anythign else it says? for instance in Genesis it says, on the seventh day God rested. now if we take that into acount for a billion or so years....... he rested for that long? and if it also says we should work 6 days then rest for the seventh... are we supposed to rest for a billion years? We have to take what the bible says literally otherwise we cant rely on it for anything This throws off A LOT of people. "rice you be cray~zey!"
They want to ask why these weird things happened, why there is a universe, and why this universe. Perhaps science cannot answer such questions. Science is good at telling us how, but not so good on the why. Maybe there isn't a why. To wonder why is very human, but perhaps there is no answer in human terms to such deep questions of existence. Or perhaps there is, but we are looking at the problem in the wrong way.
Quote from: Who_ate_my_rice;1312308Can you give me some evidence bru~ would be cool to have a look. nothign being smart here, im seriously asking.This is a really good presentation, I admit, before watching it, I didn't really have much of an understand of what the cosmic background radiation was and what it meant. But this explains it really well.http://www.jpl.nasa.gov/events/lectures_archive.cfm?year=2009&month=6Quote from: Who_ate_my_rice;1312308ah~ see Toofast, its not to us because if we can't believe in the bible to tell us how the world began, how can we rely on anythign else it says? for instance in Genesis it says, on the seventh day God rested. now if we take that into acount for a billion or so years....... he rested for that long? and if it also says we should work 6 days then rest for the seventh... are we supposed to rest for a billion years? We have to take what the bible says literally otherwise we cant rely on it for anything This throws off A LOT of people. "rice you be cray~zey!"This is where I disagree with you, there are many Christians which interpret the bible metaphorically, and for good reason to.
Quote from: Blob_ZPS;1312311Not just everything, everywhere and everywhen came into being too. There wasnt anything before so its not like it magically appeared, the universe always was and always will be.You contracting yourself there aren't you, you say it came into being, then say it always was?I was just reading through this, quite interestinghttp://www.fortunecity.com/emachines/e11/86/big-bang.htmlThe second to last paragraph sums it up nicelyQuoteThey want to ask why these weird things happened, why there is a universe, and why this universe. Perhaps science cannot answer such questions. Science is good at telling us how, but not so good on the why. Maybe there isn't a why. To wonder why is very human, but perhaps there is no answer in human terms to such deep questions of existence. Or perhaps there is, but we are looking at the problem in the wrong way.
Don't get me wrong there will be people in those churches who are Born Again. Once again i state that its not your attendance to a particular church which saves you, or how much you tithe or what you do for people that will get you to heaven. Its your personal relationship with Jesus Christ. And if you aren't born again you cant. My pastor said to me, a lot of these people who said they were a christian, they didn't have a relationship with Jesus. If they did, they'd have never left.
usoundmad
I san save puppies and kittens everyday of my life... but thats not going to get me into heaven :/ Using the bridge will!